Sleep Accessories · Best-of list
The best sleep mask is the one whose shape suits your face and your sleep position, with a strap that keeps it there until morning. This list keeps masks whose listing states a mask type and a strap, up to three of each kind and one per brand, so flat, silk, contoured, weighted and cooling masks all get a seat. I'm Rosa. I slept in daylight for seven years, so I take the dark seriously.
How this list is builtMasks with a stated type and strap, at most three of each type — flat, silk, contoured, weighted, heated, cooling — and one per brand.
We earn a commission if you buy through our links, at no cost to you. Disclosure
Good for a flat mask in mulberry silk, as the listing states, with an adjustable elastic strap you can loosen or tighten. Skip it if you want cups that keep fabric off your eyelids; this one rests on them.
Skip it if you want cups that keep fabric off your eyelids; this one rests on them.
Good for a weighted mask with a mulberry silk face, as listed, and a hook-and-loop strap. Skip it if you dislike pressure on your eyes or if hook-and-loop tends to catch your hair at the back.
Skip it if you dislike pressure on your eyes or if hook-and-loop tends to catch your hair at the back.
Good for a flat mulberry silk mask with a stated 22 momme and a 6A grade, both as listed. Skip it if you need to adjust the fit; the listing gives a non-adjustable band.
Skip it if you need to adjust the fit; the listing gives a non-adjustable band.
Good for a flat mulberry silk mask at a stated 22 momme, with a hook-and-loop strap that sets to any size. Skip it if you have long hair that snags on hook-and-loop.
Skip it if you have long hair that snags on hook-and-loop.
Good for a weighted mask with contoured cups and a buckle strap; the listing says the cups help keep lashes and eye makeup off the inner surface. Skip it if you want a stated fabric; the listing doesn't give one.
Skip it if you want a stated fabric; the listing doesn't give one.
Good for contoured cups in mulberry silk, with a stated 25 momme, a 6A grade and an adjustable elastic strap; the listing says it's contoured for lash extensions. Skip it if you sleep on your stomach and want the thinnest mask.
Skip it if you sleep on your stomach and want the thinnest mask.
Good for a plain flat cotton mask with a hook-and-loop strap; the listing claims "100% Blocking Light". Skip it if you want silk against your skin or a strap that won't touch your hair.
Skip it if you want silk against your skin or a strap that won't touch your hair.
Good for a memory foam mask with contoured cups and a buckle strap; the listing claims "100% Light Block-Out". Skip it if you sleep on your side and the cups' depth bothers you against the pillow.
Skip it if you sleep on your side and the cups' depth bothers you against the pillow.
Good for a pack of 3 plush masks with adjustable elastic straps, listed for kids. Skip it if you're buying for an adult, or if you need a stated age range; the listing doesn't give one.
Skip it if you're buying for an adult, or if you need a stated age range; the listing doesn't give one.
Good for a memory foam mask with contoured cups and an adjustable elastic strap; the listing claims "100% Blackout". Skip it if you want a natural fiber like silk or cotton against your face.
Skip it if you want a natural fiber like silk or cotton against your face.
Good for a pack of 2 satin masks, listed as weighted, with adjustable elastic straps, so one can dry while you wear the other. Skip it if you want silk; satin is satin.
Skip it if you want silk; satin is satin.
Good for a mask the listing calls cooling, with a cooling fabric over cotton filling as its stated method, and a hook-and-loop strap. Skip it if you want a chilled gel insert; this listing names fabric, not gel.
Skip it if you want a chilled gel insert; this listing names fabric, not gel.
Every mask here states two things in its listing: what type of mask it is, and what kind of strap holds it on. Those two fields decide most of the fit, so a mask that skips either one didn't make the list.
Then we spread the list across the kinds of mask. No more than three of any one type made it in: flat, silk, contoured, weighted, heated or cooling. And only one mask per brand. That keeps one shape from taking over the page, and it keeps a single brand from filling it with colors of the same mask.
The order isn't a ranking from best to worst. Masks are too personal for that. A contoured foam mask can be the right answer for one sleeper and a headache for the next. Read the list by kind and pick the kind first.
Every spec in the table and in the notes comes from the maker or the Amazon listing, as stated. Words like "100% blackout" are the seller's claim, shown in quotes. We don't rate how dark a mask is.
Light is the loudest signal your body clock gets. The NIGMS, part of the NIH, says light and dark have the biggest influence on circadian rhythms, and that light from devices at night can confuse that clock. A mask doesn't change your schedule. It makes the room dark at the one spot that counts, your eyelids, when the room won't cooperate.
For seven years, from 2009 to 2016, I hosted an overnight radio show. I slept from about 9 a.m. to 4 p.m. with aluminum foil taped over my bedroom windows. It worked, mostly. The light got in at the edges, where the tape gave up.
That's the lesson I bring to masks. Darkness fails at the edges. On a mask, the edges are the bridge of your nose and the sides near your temples. A strap that's loose lets the mask shift, and a shifted mask lets the light in. So when you read this list, read the strap column like it matters, because it does.
My one opinion on masks: if you're unsure, start with the strap, not the fabric. The reason is in the table. A mask that moves lets light in at the edges, and the strap column is the only field that tells you how it's held on.
Material shows as stated: mulberry silk, cotton, memory foam, satin, plush. A mask counts as silk on this page only when the listing says mulberry silk. Satin is a weave, not a fiber, and satin masks are listed as satin here. The FTC requires textile labels to give the generic fiber name and the percentage by weight, so the fiber line on the package is the one to trust. A title that says "silky" is a mood.
Momme is a weight measure for silk; higher means denser fabric. It shows only when the listing gives a number. A grade like 6A is the seller's quality label, not a public certification, and it shows "as listed".
If you've ever woken up with your mask on your forehead, the strap is usually why. (Jules says I wake up looking like a ski goggle commercial. Jules is not wrong.)
Three flat masks in mulberry silk made the list, each from a different brand. The ALASKA BEAR mask lists mulberry silk and an adjustable elastic strap. The BLISSY mask states 22 momme and a 6A grade, as listed, with a non-adjustable band. The Drowsy Featherweight Silk Sleep Mask states 22 momme too, with a hook-and-loop strap.
So the choice inside this group comes down to the strap. If you want to set the fit yourself, look at the elastic or hook-and-loop options. If you hate anything that adjusts, the fixed band is the plain one.
The Fishers Finery mask pairs contoured cups with mulberry silk, a stated 25 momme, a 6A grade and an adjustable elastic strap. Its listing says it's "Contoured for Lash Extensions". The FYGRIP and Gritin masks are memory foam with contoured cups. FYGRIP uses a buckle; Gritin uses adjustable elastic. Both listings make a full light-blocking claim in their own words.
Silk or foam is the decision here. Foam holds the cup shape. Silk is the softer face, and the care tag usually asks for more patience.
The Baloo mask lists a mulberry silk face, a weighted build and a hook-and-loop strap. The FACEMOON mask is weighted with contoured cups and a buckle strap, and the listing says the cups help keep lashes and eye makeup away from the inner surface. The Kitsch listing is a pack of 2 satin masks, listed as weighted, with adjustable elastic straps.
A note on weight: none of these listings gave us a stated mask weight we could show, so the table can't compare them by heaviness. Compare by fabric and strap instead.
The FRESHME mask is plain cotton with a hook-and-loop strap and the claim "100% Blocking Light". The Geyoga listing is a pack of 3 plush masks with adjustable elastic, sold as a kids' item. Its listing doesn't state an age range, so we can't tell you one. The LitBear mask is the cooling pick: the listing names a cooling fabric over cotton filling as the method, with a hook-and-loop strap.
No heated mask is in the list at our last check. If one qualifies later, it will show up in the table with its heat source, and the maker's heating instructions are the ones to follow.
A mask you can't wash easily is a mask you stop wearing. Read the care tag before you decide. Margo's rule is "read the care tag before the price tag", and on a mask it's even more true, because it sits on your face every night.
A few listings mention OEKO-TEX. OEKO-TEX STANDARD 100 means the textile was tested for harmful substances, and you can check a certificate number on the OEKO-TEX Label Check. We show it only when the listing states it.
A sleep mask is a fabric cover for your eyes, not a health device. Any wording in a listing about sleep quality, relaxation or skin is the maker's, and we don't repeat it as a promise. If light isn't what keeps you awake, a mask won't fix what is. The CDC's list of sleep habits starts with a regular bedtime and a quiet, relaxing, cool bedroom; a mask helps with just one piece of that.
Take a mask off if it irritates your skin or eyes, or if it presses hard enough to leave marks. If you've had eye surgery or have an eye condition, ask your eye doctor before you wear anything over your eyes at night. For a kids' mask, follow the maker's guidance and make sure the child can take it off on their own.
Masks are a common December gift, and they're easy to get wrong in one specific way: you don't know the other person's head, hair or sleep position. So lean on the fields that forgive a guess.
Skip the weighted kind as a surprise. Pressure on the eyes is a personal preference, and nobody should find out at 2 a.m. that they hate it. The sleep gifts page has more ideas built the same way.
If your bedroom is already dark and you sleep through the night, you don't need a mask. Keep your money and your eyelids free.
You can also skip it if:
Sleep well.
There isn't one for everybody. The best eye mask for sleeping is the one that fits your sleep position and stays on. Back sleepers can wear any shape. Side sleepers usually do better with a thin flat mask. Lash wearers and people who blink a lot look at contoured cups. Start with the mask type column, then the strap.
Better at feel, not at darkness. A mulberry silk mask is smooth and light and slides on a pillowcase. Cotton is simple and usually easy to wash. Memory foam holds a contoured shape. Light blocking depends on the shape and the fit at your nose more than on the fabric. Choose silk for the fiber, and check the care tag before you choose.
A weighted mask adds gentle pressure over your eyes from a filled layer. Some people like that feeling and some can't stand it. Makers describe what the weight is for in their own words, and we don't repeat those claims as fact. If you're not sure, a light flat mask is the lower-risk first try.
Fit the strap, not just the mask. An adjustable elastic, buckle or hook-and-loop strap lets you set the tension. A fixed band has to fit your head as made. The strap should sit above your ears without leaving a dent. If the mask still ends up on your forehead, try a slimmer one that the pillow doesn't push.
Your care tag decides how, and your face decides how often. A mask sits on your skin all night, so many people wash it about as often as a pillowcase. Silk and memory foam often say hand wash. Owning two masks makes this easy: one dries while you wear the other.
